Submit Your Contribution to the Debate

denotes an essay length item or published paper

Professor R. C. Tallis Burying Freud
Dr Tim Kendall - Review of Webster's Why Freud Was Wrong
Bob Hinshelwood - A lot of heartache has been spent on this Tallis's article...
J. Alexis Burland, MD - Let me first thank you very much for making this article available...
Dr Ivan Goldberg - Professor Tallis' attacks Freud as a scientist and as a person...
Bruce A Thyer - Those who enjoyed Professor Taliss's commentary on Webster's book...
Pam Michaud - I appreciated your review of Webster's intellectual biography...
Baudouin Jurdant - Once again ! It would be interesting to review...
Michael Zeitlin - Yes indeed, touché. Elisabeth Roudinesco...
Jonathan Ames - Thanks to those who made this article accessible, it was interesting material...
Patricia Elliot - In some respects, the forwarded message from Dr. I. Goldberg...
Dr John O'Neil - A brief and clear essay. Right in many details, mistaken overall...
Professor Norman Holland - I'm puzzled. In the responses to...
Dr Harvey Schwartz - This is a rather strange posting. Dr. Golberg states that psychoanalysis...
David Westbrook - I would like to add my own puzzlement at the notion...
Jeff Long - Unfortunately, one phenomenon of this new media of discussion...
Dr Jacques Siboni - My conclusion here is a bit different...
Jonathan Ames - I don't think the "testability" of psychoanalysis is as much the core...
Dr Dominique Scarfone - Were it not for the dire consequences in terms of intellectual loss...
Bob Hinshelwood - My sense is to agree (partly) with Jonathan Ames...
Bernard X. Bovasso - You overlook something vital in your proposition:...
Professor Gregory Bovasso - I agree that a devaluing of critical introspection...
Dr John O'Neil - Bernard X. Bovasso replied to my first long posting...
Bernard X. Bovasso - The burying of Freud and the quest...
Dr John O'Neil - I was just rereading you posting, which had sent me to the...
Paul Williams - Freud-Baiting
Jonathan Ames - I didn't intend to suggest or support a polarization...
Professor Frederick Crews - Confessions of a Freud Basher
Professor Frederick Crews - Response to Jonathan Lear's article in the New Republic
Bernard X. Bovasso - Since *the erotic* may be understood to prevail in tandem...
Jonathan Ames - Sure -- death is certainly a threat to humanity. I think "control" per se...
Bernard X. Bovasso - I certainly did not consider what you had to say "narrowly scientistic"...
Bernard X. Bovasso - The point I was also making, especially that you brought it up...
gls@tiac.net - Maybe there is something else you want to judge, kill, and remove...
Dr Don Routh - I cannot claim to have a detailed knowledge of Edward Erwin's book...
Dr Tim Kendall - I haven't read this [Edward Erwin] but its likely to follow similar lines...
Dr Jerry Davison - Thought you might be interested to know that I was a colleague of Erwin's...
Professor Daniel Dupertuis - Science and Psychoanalysis: a non-existent opposition
Matt Wells - I cannot say that I am acquainted with Erwin, but the claim that elements...
Dr Charles Brenner - Psychoanalysis: Philosophy or Science
Jonathan Ames - I wonder if ANY belief system can receive significant confirmation...
Bernard X. Bovasso - Although Freud may have been eager to find acceptance for his ideas
Jeff Long - Please correct me if I have a misunderstanding of Freud's work
Adrian Ortiz - "Lapsed Baptist","faithfull",Biblical scripture","Bible Belt"...
gls@analysis.com - The confirmatory evidence of the tenets of psychoanalysis is like...
Professor Jonathan Lear - A Counterblast in the War on Freud
Professor Frederick Crews - Norman Holland says he can understand why...
Dr Eric Gillett - I am interested in trying to get some version of "Grünbaum v. Crews"
Dr Paulo Teitelbaum - In short, I think one should be extremely cautious...
Professor Frederick Crews - Freud Evaluated: The Completed Arc by Malcolm Macmillan
Peter Freyd - Crime Victims' Compensation and Repressed Memory
Adrian Ortiz - We are interested in the debate about the differences between psychoanalysis...
Dr Paul Hamburg - Freud: Ad Hominem versus the cult of Empiricism
Dr Dominique Scarfone - The point Frederick Crews tries to make against Freud...
Valerie O'Farrell - I was excited to see Bob Hinshelwood's comments...
Professor Frederick Crews - "Science"
Dr Eric Gillet - Grünbaum versus Crews
Professor Daniel G. Dupertuis - I can t quite understand this, above all if one has read the...
Bernard X. Bovasso - On the other hand, an hermeneutic approach...
Jonathan Ames - God! How "scientifically" is Foucault hereby dished!
T. W. Camp - Psychoanalysis is about human experience and how to be as open...
Professor John F. Kihlstrom - Psychodynamics and Social Cognition: Notes on the Fusion of Psychoanalysis and Psychology
Dr Eric Gillet - Eagle versus Crews
Rolf Hamburger - Must Freud be Buried?,,,
Rolf Hamburger - Dr. Ivan Goldberg writes: "It is hard to see how...
Jeremy Holmes - The Assault on Freud
Dr Howard Eisman - I welcome Jeremy Holmes' description of the "new" psychoanalysis..
Allen Esterson - Response to Rolf Hamburger on penile erections in REM sleep
Gibbs A. Williams, Ph.D. - On the Absurd Notion of Burying Freud.
Lawrence Wiley - Freud's Great Contribution
Frederick Crews - Freud Debate at Yale -Unconscious Deeps and Empirical Shallows
Frederick Crews - Unauthorized Freud: Doubters Confront a Legend
Dr. Roberto P. Neuburger - A chronicle of the announced death of psychoanalysis
Frank Kegan - I am a Ph.D. student in psychology, who was raised on Freud
Robert E Haskell - Psychoanalysis and cognitive science
Peter Letz - Psychoanalysis - The Freudian Religion 

Mental Health Bestsellers

(See also UK Bestsellers)

human-nature.com © Ian Pitchford and Robert M. Young - Last updated: 28 May, 2005 02:29 PM